Winning the Allardyce way - Thoughts on Newcastle 1, Wigan 0
By Bob Yule On Sun 2 Sep 2007 |
Nick Hornby once described George Graham as a wise father-figure. Whilst many Arsenal fans pleaded for brighter football, and were baffled by his decisions, George calmly imposed his own ideas, knowing full well that the road to success was often an ugly one, and there was no point in trying to please people along the way. Arsenal ground their way to two league titles, and of course no-one complained. Our relationship with Big Sam may be on similar lines.
The 1-0 win on Saturday mirrored the other performances that have brought us two wins, two draws and no defeats. The defence is solid, the midfield is organised and while the football is hardly spectacular, the players have the relaxed air of playing to a plan that they believe in.
Like German teams of old, we kept to our pattern from first minute to last, and patience was rewarded. It was very much the sort of game that we could have lost. Complete domination, no goals, and everyone can start to think that it’s just not our day. Someone then takes an unnecessary risk, and the game is lost. If nothing else, Allardyce has instilled some real composure and professionalism into the team.
It looked to me like a typical Michael Owen performance. He missed a couple of fairly easy chances, but that’s par for the course. I’ve always felt that his conversion rate wasn’t that good, partly because anything falling on his left foot is liable to be scuffed. But he has always been great at reading the game and getting into the right position a split second before his marker, and so it proved. He darted to the near post at just the right time to nod in Martins’ inviting cross.
Cacapa looks like a great signing. He looks quick and strong enough to deal with most situations, and most importantly, he has an air of calm authority about him. Since the departure of Woodgate, we’ve lacked a real leader at the back, but he really seems to fit the bill.
The midfield looked as dogged as ever, but lacked pace. That was supplied by Zoggy, who produced a number of surging runs that took him through the Wigan midfield. He does look good attacking from full back, where he has the time to take the ball without pressure, spot a gap and accelerate into the space beyond. He wasn’t really tested in defence, but it’s clear that he’s growing in confidence and may yet hold down his place despite the signing of Enrique.
The midfield trio of Geremi, Butt and Smith has been criticised for a lack of creativity. Well, that may be true, but does Allardyce have better options at the moment, in the absence of Barton and Emre? I’d say no. Rather than complaining, perhaps we should be thinking that if Allardyce can get results with that trio, how much better will it be when Barton supplies that extra bit of attacking threat.
Judging from this and our previous games, we’re becoming a side that other teams don’t particularly want to face, rather like the old Bolton. We’re prepared to give the opposition a hard time, and look much more mentally strong than previous teams, going right back to the Keegan days.
It’s clear that Allardyce has convinced his players that his way is the right way. I’m certainly not going to argue.

Complaints about boring functional football? Where have folk been for the past 3 years?
Give me boring functional football anyday over the haphazard displays of cluelessness we’ve been treated to under Souness and Roeder. We looked solid and created chances despite missing 3 creative midfielders through injury, having our main striker working towards match sharpness and half of the squad being recent acquisitions.
Folk should give the lads a chance, booing for failing to beat a good Villa team (2-0 chelsea anyone) was a joke, especially seeing as the press no longer have freddie, bramble, dyer, etc to pick on so are no turning on us fans
Sent in on: September 5th, 2007 (3 weeks ago) at 12:02 pm
Hope I’m wrong but afraid I can’t agree with most of the previous comments.
The football is functional and boring and let’s face it, the team were just three minutes away from being booed off on Saturday (albeit, probably muted booing).
Comparisons with the Keegan era are ridiculous. Ominously, it’s the Souness period which springs to mind _ another manager who was obsessed with clean sheets, 1-0 wins, organisation and a disregard towards entertaining the paying public.
Allardyce is likely to be more successful than GS (who wouldn’t be?!!) but I don’t think it will be too much fun watching him try to be.
Sent in on: September 4th, 2007 (3 weeks ago) at 2:47 pm
Good article, and I agree completely.
But, until Duff returns and with the sales of Dyer and Nobby, are we a bit short oo wingers? Should either Zog or Milner (which have both been outstanding thus far this season, i really like those two)be injured, I’m afraid our attaking play may suffer. And a creative ACM like Deco could be a godsend, just look what SA did with Jay Jay!
Sent in on: September 4th, 2007 (3 weeks ago) at 4:41 am
Spot on I agree completely, good article.
Sent in on: September 3rd, 2007 (3 weeks ago) at 12:38 pm
its looking good so far but ther is a hell of a long way to go, in this season and the next.
am so sick of these international games, so stupidhaving them a few games into the season ther pointless, the idiots who dedcided on the dates should be sacked.
anyways, we shud of signed another ACM imo but regardless good result cnt wait for derby game
Sent in on: September 3rd, 2007 (3 weeks ago) at 12:21 pm
I could not agree more with your statement on our midfield. Yeah we aren’t the most creative of teams at the moment and yet we’ve had great results. On top of that once we get Barton, Emre and (dare i say) Duff back from injury we will have a much more creative midfield and will be able to properly use our wingers (Milner and N’Zogbia) with a strong spine between them capable of creating chances and helping out the defence.
Also, once we get Beye and Enrique to settle we will have gone from having one of the leakiest defences in the league to arguably one of the tightest. BS has been faultless so far and has been the man to get rid of the overpaid shit that we have had to endure for far too long.
I’m trying not to get carried away as it is the Toon after all but without a doubt a top-6 finish is a very real possibility for us this season….maybe even higher!
Sent in on: September 3rd, 2007 (3 weeks ago) at 3:34 am
I agree with most of that article.
I’m also happy with the way were playing for now, it’s nice going into the last 10minutes of a game not feeling anxious. Sam’s brought in a good quality batch of players and shipped out a lot of the deadwood, Babayaro and Carr are 2 others I’d have got rid of but they’re now only backup anyways.
As for the current team and style of play, N’zogbia is currently wasted at LB, he’s not good enough defensively to play that position week in week out (which will show in the future against better wingers), and to be honest I don’t see the point in wasting his great forward play by making him hold back, He will look twice the player he has ever been for us with Enrique behind him rather than the shocking Babayaro who offers no backup to the wingers. I think that once Enrique is match fit he should be played allowing N’zogbia to take up a more advanced role to add some “flair” to the attack.
Winning the “Allardyce way” is all good to me, cause I’d rather win something and take points in as many games as possible.
I do think alot of people are underestimating Sam though, He played the way he did at Bolton cause he didnt have star players in their prime knocking at his door to add quality to their side, He now has players who can win games with their class as well as with his workrate and patience style of football.
He’s already said Good results buy you time at big clubs, and He needed instant results so he went with what he knows, I think that over the season we’ll see him try a more attacking type of football against “lesser” sides, He’s got to build up the club and squad till he’s happy to experiment though and thats a long process considering the state it was in as he took over.
Either way, Winning is first and foremost, we’ve been too long without a trophy and anyone taking positive actions to change that other than throwing cash at players gets my backing….
Looking forward to the season, the longer we remain unbeaten the better, Derby after the international break is exactly what we need to show we’re not the same old Newcastle, that will drop points to the leagues whipping boys.
Sent in on: September 3rd, 2007 (3 weeks ago) at 12:47 am