A game that was perhaps ineffable in the truer sense of the term left many feeling confused as to how they should be feeling. Had Newcastle lost valiantly? Had Newcastle expended copious amounts of energy and effort for nothing? It all depends on how you want to look at things. This game evinced enough to both depress the optimistic and elate the cynic concurrently.

On one hand, Newcastle were capable of frustrating a Chelsea side that had precious ground to make up on Manchester United away from home for 74 minutes without resorting to ugly football, with a side that can only aptly be described as second-string. On the other hand, all Newcastle could do was delay the inevitable deathblow that Drogba ultimately delivered after Chelsea had fielded a weakened team. The inevitability of this is very much questionable in the minds of some though.

With a couple of vivacious players returning to the fray in the next week or so, our next meeting with Chelsea in the Carling Cup should provide more insight into the game just passed; is Roeder’s squad capable of more when our supposed big guns return, or is pointing to the youth and inexperience of the side a convenient intrigue that provides relative safety in lauding a result that almost was? Indeed, was that as good as it gets, or will the ever-present potential be fulfilled in any form any time soon?

That isn’t to belittle such an unexpected result and performance, but it would be a sad day when a Newcastle fan no longer wished to push on from a 1-0 defeat at Stamford Bridge, while improvement upon it was still a very realistic possibility. What difference would Kieron Dyer, Nolberto Solano and Emre have made?

Carling Cup: Newcastle United vs Chelsea 20-12-06

Game: Chelsea (a)

Goal: Didier Drogba

Blame: Nicky Butt

Reason: He was just an extra number at the back until the ball was played into Shevchenko - it was only then that he realised that defending is about more than just being in the defensive zone. If more alert, he could have easily been goalside of Shevchenko before Terry had even laid the ball off to Robben.

BLAME COUNT - Season 06/07

Responsible For 4 Goals Conceded

Stephen Carr
Celestine Babayaro

Responsible For 2 Goals Conceded

Scott Parker
Peter Ramage
Steven Taylor

Responsible For 1 Goal Conceded

Titus Bramble
Steve Harper
Craig Moore
Nolberto Solano
Shay Given
Nicky Butt