N-O Panel: Post-Match Chelsea (a)
By Jonny Hall On Mon 31 Dec 2007 |
A hard battling performance was not enough to stop Chelsea from taking all three points at Stamford Bridge on Saturday afternoon, as they came 2-1 winners over Newcastle. Despite fighting back to make it 1-1 through Nicky Butt, and looking like the side most likely to end Chelsea’s unbeaten home record, a clearly offside goal from Kalou gave the former-Champions the victory. We got our panel’s reaction…
Rich
“We wuz robbed, Guvnor!
Technically, yes we were, but that still doesn’t tell you the whole story here. The linesman got it horribly wrong and cost us our first point at Stamford Bridge since August 2001, but in truth can anyone really say we deserved anything from this game after the way in which we approached the final 20 minutes? Yes, we were better than we had been recently, but we were hardly expansive – especially after we equalised!
When it got to 1-1, many people could have been forgiven for allowing themselves to think that the impossible may really happen. For all intents and purposes Chelsea were struggling, the crowd was on Grant’s back, and they probably only had 2 first-choice players on the park when Sinclair came on for them. All of it looked set for a Highbury-esque result (1-3 back under Sir Bobby), but then we did what the New Newcastle always do and tried to sit back.
People will say that bringing Michael Owen on for Obafemi Martins was not a defensive move, and they are right, but it was not a sensible move. It robbed us of our only attacking outlet and which allowed Chelsea to defend higher up the pitch, compress the play, and swing the balance of the game back in their favour. After it went to 1-1 we looked the more likely to score, Martins providing a great cross for Duff that Belletti did well to intercept, and then we made that change.
What did we do after Michael Owen came on the pitch? Absolutely nowt. Now I will admit that I’m not Mo’s biggest fan, but this isn’t a personal tirade against him – he simply cannot be expected to play the lone striker role, it is not his game, if we were truly serious about trying to win then surely the obvious substitutions would have been Owen and Viduka for the injured Smith and the unfit Duff? I’m not usually one to nitpick like this, but it was plainly obvious to me during the game that Allardyce’s substitutions cost us the point as much as the linesman did.
A draw would have been a decent result – even though we were really playing a Chelsea XI rather than the real deal – but the loss made all the more disappointing by the fact that we could have won here for the first time since 1986. A win here would have seriously relieved the pressure on Allardyce and his squad, but I’m not sure if he had either the nouse or the bollocks to go for it.
Thankfully, he looks like keeping his job and so he should get time to make up for this “mistake†in the future, I hope to God that he does so.
Man of the Match: Abdoulaye Faye”
Tom
“Saturday’s performance has left me feeling disappointed.
The performance was a big improvement, and I felt that we matched Chelsea well. Looking back at replays confirmed for me the reports that Kalou’s ‘goal’ was offside, so we I feel that we were unlucky not to take a point from the game.
I can’t really argue with the performance in this game, although I’m left wondering a couple things. Number one, can we maintain the good performances. Looking at the season so far suggests not. The pattern seems to be turning in a good performance for a game or two, before returning to the same old dross. Secondly, performing well against teams like Chelsea and Arsenal is all very well, but it’s of little use when we’re failing to take points from the likes of Derby and Wigan.”
Jonny
“Why do we even bother anymore?
Against the odds, Newcastle went, matched (and to an extent outplayed) Chelsea on their own turf, and came away with nothing thanks to some dodgy officiating. Salomon Kalou was clearly standing near on FOUR YARDS offside when the ball deflected to him from Claudio Pizzaro, yet the forward was allowed to skip his way past Shay Given and give Chelsea the victory; the flag that should have followed, didn’t.
To make matters even more shocking, Shay Given, Abdoulaye Faye and Charles N’Zogbia were booked for protesting the decision. Newcastle surrounded the referee, and his assistant who didn’t make the decision, yet they still didn’t question the decision. Big Sam’s words post-match summed the whole thing up:
“Managers are losing their jobs sooner than ever and that means there is even more pressure on decisions. That was a horrid decision. I wouldn’t mind being fined for criticising but what is the point? The Chelsea player was three yards offside. It is certainly the worst decision against me this year. But referee Mike Riley should have gone over to linesman Mike Cairns and given him time to change his mind.”
How can he expected to fight for his job when the football officials aren’t even doing their jobs? It’s pathetic that someone can get such a decision wrong, and that Newcastle are now without no points from that game. To make matters even worse, they can’t appeal to anyone for the points as once the final whistle goes, there’s nothing more than can be done even if the ref wanted to.
From the rest of the game, we should be proud. For a large period of the second half, we dictated play and were in it right up to the Chelsea winner. The Nicky Butt goal was scrappy, but we deserved it. If any time was going to win it after that, you wouldn’t have been mistaken in believing it could have been us. Chelsea’s quality was always better than ours however, and in the end our defensive, sit-on-a-result attitude beat us again.
Maybe I’m living in dreamland, but it sure as hell would have been great to be the first side to win at Stamford Bridge since February 2004. Sadly, as with most things Newcastle, it wasn’t meant to be.
MOTM: Abdoulaye Faye - An absolute rock in midfield and a credit to the shirt.”

Johnny… Apart from the double negative, you only really you only really pertain to the real reason we lost a point at Chelsea.
Rich… you hit the nail on the head but don’t go far enough in condemning Allerdyce’s tactics.
This was a hugely below par Chelsea side however, it was still not a side which we could have beaten purely because of Sam’s inferiority complex. On paper Chelski have us beaten with their ’second string’ thanks to Jose. Grant has the same uphill struggle to convince the fans that he is better than what they had. A struggle to which I don’t think he will survive. He has the same problem as Fat Sam but not the same history or expectations. Sam was frightened into a defensive decision, and as such, Chelsea smelt blood, and cost us the game. A great opportunity for Sam to point at officials and have a bit of a cry, but really the damage was already done. All I really saw from that game was some players not wanting their names dragged through the mud.
Indeed it was this game in microcosm that mirrors the malaise at the club. Even in the short term Sam has to put away his extraordinarily large ego and show faith to the Newcastle supporters that he can do more than the ‘Hump Hump’ that he is famous for. He needs to extend his repertoire through the talent we can all see on the pitch, otherwise his side will share the same fate as those of Roeder or Soonmess, as will Big Sam.
As a matter of litmus test, Sam’s signings do not bode well for Newcastle. They still need time to bed in however, they still look like bargain basement Soonmess January buys, apart from Baye and Faye. I can understand the boards reluctance to further fund such extravagant experiments. He has also made catastrophic decisions about the captaincy of the club. So we have a catalogue of errors on so many levels, his play, his buys, his managerial decisions.
All this will not help Sam as I don’t see him changing. I do see some of the players working some of the time which is also endemic of the current management. I do not wish to see Allerdyce ousted it would cost too much in terms of money and status within the current media and potential managers. A real catch 22.
Sent in on: January 1st, 2008 at 2:01 pm