The Madness of St James.
By Kitman On Thu 11 Sep 2008 |
Any toon fan out of short pants knows that the club resembles a lunatic asylum at the best of times. Terrible PR, silly wages, sillier transfer fees, maverick directors, mental players, bizarre team formations, players played out of position, crazy managerial appointments and dismissals and so on. We’ve had plenty of humiliations over the years, like Kieron Dyer’s bust-up with Lee Bowyer, and Freddie and Doug’s broadcast to the Geordie nation from a whorehouse; but we’ve been able to laugh them off by and large and move on, haven’t we? However the events of the last few days take some beating, they really do, and are totally baffling and disappointing even by NUFC standards.
When Mike Ashley took over, we all thought he would inject some much overdue professionalism and intelligence into the running of the club. However the wheels have well and truly come off now, to the extent the club resembles one of those rickety clown cars at the circus, where everything falls off the car before the fat clown gets out and trips over his feet. Except no-one on Tyneside is laughing right now, Mr Ashley. We are well and truly a club in crisis, with the Board and fans at war, and the season’s only 3 matches old! You really couldn’t make it up….
You have to wonder whether the club’s hierarchy understands much about our club at all. Like the deep affection and respect for Keegan is held in by those supporters who remember his years of service to the club on and off the field. Or the deep hole we were in when Keegan took over from Allardyce. Or the terrible impact that his departure will have on the club, the supporters and the playing staff. And don’t even get me started on Dennis f*cking Wise, a man deemed more important to the club than Keegan! It seems to me the club basically doesn’t care about the average supporter. The lack of communication with fans, the lack of significant signings, swingeing price rises, and now the forcing out of Keegan all show a basic lack of respect and appreciation for the club’s support and its traditions. As a result, for all his man of the people act, his motives in buying our club remain suspect and his failure to support Keegan in the course of this crisis has created an impression of South East vs North East and alienated supporters against him. I wouldn’t stand with the fans again in a hurry if I were you, Mike.
The fact is, we’ve been a club in decline for a long time now. Successive inept managerial appointments from Souness through to Allardyce have left the club with a mediocre and thin squad, faltering ambition and a reduced standing in the game. These issues have not really been addressed, despite the much heralded changes in the set-up. Against a bleak economic outlook, is it any wonder that people are reconsidering whether they want to spend a fortune to be bored rigid by a bunch of underachieving and overpaid self obsessed ’stars’? The cracks in our support were starting to show even before this debacle. The lack of sustained investment in first team players hasn’t helped to put bums on seats either.
In my opinion, Keegan represented far more in many people’s eyes than just another manager: he represented the hope of better things to come, and most importantly a bit of craic and entertainment on a Saturday afternoon, something to look forward to. He understood that people want to go to the match to forget their troubles, not to add to them. Now that dream has been shot at dawn, presumably we can look forward to some lickspittle Carlos the Coach-io coming in from a second rate La Liga team to rescue our season. With Dennis Wise’s players. Because this fits our wonderful ’system’. Brilliant.
Now I realise that I’m overlooking the plus points to Ashley’s tenure. He’s paid off the debt (so we’re told), so no Leeds style financial melt down for us (not that other clubs somehow manage to cope with high levels of debt and invest in their teams). And we’ve got in place a great scouting system which means in 5 or 6 years time we may or may not have a great crop of Wenger style foreign youngsters to bring into the first team, or more likely to sell to a really ‘big’ club. And we’ve got in place a fantastic management set up which means no manager will ever have to worry about finding and signing his own players ever again (well it works for Barcelona, doesn’t it?). Forgive me if I’m not creaming my pants at this point in time at all that as I survey our understaffed and mediocre squad, with our best manager since Robson in the dustbin, and another season of struggle ahead.
I’m not so naive that I don’t imagine there was fault on both sides with the Keegan debacle. Keegan is a notoriously headstrong and stubborn man for all his qualities and has a track record of threatening to walk if transfers aren’t going to his liking. But my point is this: why employ him in the first place, knowing the man he is, if this was the plan? Why employ him in a system where he would have no say in major transfer decisions, how many older style managers would tolerate that? And why put Dennis Wise in charge of the whole thing, a man who as Sir Alex Ferguson said could start an argument in an empty house? Surely all of this was totally predictable and ultimately avoidable?
However for me the craziest thing about this episode is that at this point in our history, Keegan has been allowed to walk away. For the sake of club, the players and the fans, in my opinion Ashley should have swallowed his pride and done whatever was necessary to keep him. Because this club, at this time and given its recent history, desperately needs Keegan far more than it needs Dennis Wise. Not only because of his standing with the fans, players, the media, not only because of his talent and his understanding of and love for the club, not only because of the stability that he would have brought if allowed to get on with his job, but because of the hope and energy he represented. Keegan was a man to be trusted, Ashley isn’t, it’s as simple as that. Instead we’re a laughing stock again, and we’re left high and dry without a decent manager and with the transfer window closed. And the lingering suspicion we’re owned by an asset stripper who doesn’t understand football.
In the aftermath of the announcement of Keegan’s departure, it’s natural to start a hunt for the guilty. Was it Llambias’ fault (God knows what he adds to the club by the way, it’s not as if we’re a casino)? Or Wise? Or Jiminez? Or was it Ashley who pulled the trigger or failed to step in? Or maybe even Keegan himself? But honest to God, as I sit here, I don’t care anymore, it won’t make things better. We’re in the clarts, we’ve managed to make a mess of a promising position yet again, and God knows who’ll touch the job of manager (or should I say coach) with a bargepole given what’s happened. And without the right choice of manager, and some sustained success in the near future, you’d expect our better players to move on as fast as their feet will carry them (which is not very fast in Nicky Butt’s case).
My biggest fear is, once the anger and disgust at Ashley and Wise subsides, the club will drift further into decline on the back of apathy and boredom. Prudent value for money signings, a continental style management structure, a foreign coach and La Liga style tactics, living within your means, the offer for x player was too good to turn down, anyone want to buy Michael Owen, look at our excellent balance sheet blah blah blah – not really things to get the pulse racing are they? It speaks volumes that many people are praying for an Indian billionaire to rescue us from our current billionaire owner - so much for Ashley’s brave new world.
For me, that’s why letting Keegan go was an act of madness. Football isn’t a business like any other, it’s about hopes and dreams, fun and passion. For me, that’s what Keegan stood for, he was passionate and honest and knew what the fans wanted, and you knew he wouldn’t let the players short change the fans. Instead another period of decline and disappointment beckons. The fall out from this disaster could be long and sustained, and I really wonder whether this will be the last straw for many toon fans, I hope I’m wrong. The lunatics have taken over the asylum and God help us.

Never Have truer words been spoken(or typed whichever way you look at it)
Sent in on: September 13th, 2008 at 5:58 pm
We have started a website suggesting a fan buyout of Newcastle. Check it out and let us know if you think it is possible.
https://www.savenewcastle.com
Sent in on: September 13th, 2008 at 1:35 pm
excellent piece of writing.
The two best managers at Newcastle in recent years -Kev and Wor Bobby - old style managers doing the job, managing the team, instilling passion into the players and reminding them what it means to hundreds of thousands of ordinary people when they pull on the black and white and hit the turf running.
Geordies are born and bred Mike, it’s not something you can buy into. So sell now, you have had your ‘fun’.
Sent in on: September 12th, 2008 at 7:17 pm
I have been watching the toon for fifty years and even the bad old days of lord westwood and his cronies dont match up to this fiasco
I agree with everything you say a brilliant informative piece
Sent in on: September 12th, 2008 at 6:46 pm
I’ve spent the last 11 days trawling the net for article and opinion on this sorry state of affairs, and nothing resonates with me like this article. You don’t offer much hope mate, but why should you? There’s very little to be found. I’m not a doom mongerer by nature but this travesty has pushed me to the brink… I think even Francis Ford Coppolla would’ve thrown the towel if he’d had to brave the events of Apocalypse Toon
Sent in on: September 11th, 2008 at 6:31 pm
One thing we have to remember.
Let’s not have all this crap stop us from supporting the eleven players who are out on the field on Saturday. Regardless of what we think about those in charge, the players on the pitch deserve and need our support.
Howay the lads.
Sent in on: September 11th, 2008 at 5:18 pm
Brilliant article. Summed up more or less how I feel. I’ve been a die hard Newcastle fan most of my life however I’m so appalled at the way Kevin Keegan (a boyhood hero) and we (the fans have been treated) that I’m on the point of not caring anymore. I don’t have a season ticket but still managed to get to a couple of games each season but now I can’t see myself going back to St James Park until Ashley and Wise have gone!
Sent in on: September 11th, 2008 at 3:47 pm
Well said and true! - Ashley gave some hope when he arrived as an English owner. And when Keegan was signed, I was sure about better times for Toon. Now it seems Ashley can be the biggest dissaster in history for NUFC. I doubt it’s any owner/chairman that have crushed the fans’ hope and dreams in a way like Ashley have done. Is he a Mackem in disguise? It looks to be directed to be as terrible it could be….
It’s difficult to have positive thoughts about future for NUFC with Ashley’s regime at SJP. With having Keegan for some months, just to see him leave does it even worse. Looks like Ashley only wanted to show us fans the finger…. Ashley: Please sell and leave. You only hurt.
Sent in on: September 11th, 2008 at 12:57 pm
Good summery, I agree with just about everything you say, the anger is tangible. Its back to the old ‘Despair I can cope with, - its the optimism that really hurts’ Buts its not over yet..
I think the fans may still have a big say in what happens. If DW and Gollum remain in post the rift with the fans will never heal properly, but I recon we have about two weeks, before apathy sets in.
Sadly Matches are the only opportunity we have to demonstrate our anger and frustration at the club, in front of the media
Hull will be rather a mix of Boycott and non-boycott, but the fans response to Spurs game could be crucial.
The results at both fixtures will be important to what will happen next, and will effect how long the fans continue to pressurise the club.
MA has p*ssed in his chips, so we got to prey that he that he sells, I think its time he moved on from football, take modest profit and find a new interest -go on Mike buy a film studio and move Hollywood. . . a perfect dream ending.
Sent in on: September 11th, 2008 at 12:14 pm
Great piece. Well done.
Sent in on: September 11th, 2008 at 12:01 pm
this is the most accurate reading i’ve seen in a long time. Totally agree with you and can only point out more negatives then positives. Just wish (as you say) that mike ashley swallowed his pride and takes keegan back and gives him all the powers he needs (and of course sacks dennis wise) heres dreaming and heres to a very dark, worrying and upsetting season.
Sent in on: September 11th, 2008 at 11:27 am
Good article and a comprehensive summay of the thoughts of most fans.I have supported the club for over 50 years and this is by far the worst time in my recollection of the history of the club.Our decline started when instead of building on the Bobby Robson years he was sacked.He should have been given the task of finding his successor and then moved “upstairs” as they say.
What we have now after the closing years of Freddy S is a club in freefall.The supporters are either angry or totally so appalled at what has happened they no longer care.I would much prefer that Ashley,Wise and the others in the leadership mix departed and we were allowed to be Newcastle United Football Club again.It will take along time to get our dignity and pride back and to do so we need leadership in the board room and on the training pitch of the highest quality before we will do so.It will be a long way back and I am beginning to wonder whether I really care anymore.I am pleased at least I only renewed my long time held season tickets for one year and was not duped into a three year deal.
Sent in on: September 11th, 2008 at 11:08 am
Well said, I always thought Keegan would walk at some point but putting London based Wise in charge of recruitment and ” strategy” is a move so stupid you might think Ashley is deliberatley trying to wreck things.
Newcastle has had too many managers who have been sacked too quickly and has been the home of too many expensive troubled ” names” {Eg Bellamy,Bowyer, Dyer, Kliverts, Barton etc etc} that the big sensible clubs won’t touch. They do need a longer term strategy but not one developed by the gang of overpaid spivs Ashley has recruited.
In the short term I see struggle, the squad is thin and most of the experienced players are either past their best {Butt}, injury prone {Owen}, or a combination of the 2 { Viduca}.
Sent in on: September 11th, 2008 at 11:08 am
Spot on Champ…
The Dream is over,
What can i say
The Dream is over,
Yesterday
Keegan was the Dream Weaver,
Now he’s gone
Ashley was the Billionaire rescuer,
Now its all gone wrong…QUNT!
Sent in on: September 11th, 2008 at 10:54 am
It’s good to read the opinions of people who share exactly the same views as myself. Let’s hope a few more like us turn up to protest OUTSIDE the ground on Saturday.
One point you didn’t make (which I think I would have), is one MA made shortly after his buyout, about wanting to have some ‘fun’. I hope your having fun now Mike, as I know I’m not!!!
Sent in on: September 11th, 2008 at 10:44 am
i think you have summed up how a true supporter feels about the toon
Sent in on: September 11th, 2008 at 10:44 am
Good article and your right
Sent in on: September 11th, 2008 at 10:43 am