Newcastle-Online.com NUFC Supporters Forum Toon Ale - Wor Geordies Pride Is Deep Inside

Home

Season 2004-05

Nufc News Archive

Articles

St. James' Park

Toon Army

Nufc History

Nufc Forum

   
Articles Main

Toon Player Ratings Vs Sporting Lisbon (h)


8th April 2005

Shay GivenShay Given

Had little to do other than to deal with one or two crosses, a few back passes and to sweep up play. came off at half-time with his hip injury flaring up again. Fingers crossed he will be fit for our FA Cup Semi-Final match in Cardiff.

6

Stephen CarrStephen Carr

Not a great game from the Republic of Ireland man who was often up against two men with his right flank partner Dyer drifting in field a lot leaving him exposed. Could have done better in the final 3rd too but he worked hard and did his bit if you like.

6

Andy O'BrienAndy O'Brien

A nervous wreck throughout, not helped by the moans and groans from the crowd whenever he did something remotely wrong. He did grow in statue however, winning a few balls and clearing danger. But his general defending and distribution distribution from the back gets worse with every game. I hate to criticise him because he's an honest, hard working player who gives his all but at this level it's not good enough. Thankfully Sporting didn't know what to do with the ball in and around our box.

5

Steven TaylorSteven Taylor

His full debut at centre-half? Started the game very nervously with a spate of rash challenges but I'll put that down to an eagerness to get over Saturday's red card. He soon found his stride though and was solid at the back, assured and a leader. My man of the match and he now has to stay in there alongside Boumsong.

8

Aaron HughesAaron Hughes

A similar job to Carr, not the greatest performances but he did his job playing out of position at left-back. Slightly better going forward but not as good in defence as Carr. All in all a solid enough game but nothing spectacular. Was booked and misses the return leg.

6

Kieron DyerKieron Dyer

One or two bright moments from Dyer but overall he was largely anonymous. Didn't get on the ball much and when he did find space to run into the ball wasn't forthcoming often or quick enough. Worked hard and tracked back but if he is to play wide right he must be more disciplined and stop coming in field all the time as it leaves poor Carr exposed. Pulled up with what looks like a hamstring injury and was subbed by his big pal Bowyer...

5

Jermaine JenasJermaine Jenas

Worked hard throughout, never let his head drop despite numerous moans and groans from the crowd and got stuck in once or twice but he clearly lacks confidence and on the ball he was awful, much like the rest of the team. Where now for JJ?

5

Amdy FayeAmdy Faye

The pick of midfield (which isn't saying much) with a solid if rather hasty job in protecting the back-four. gave away possession far too cheaply however and wandered about aimlessly for large spells, again like most of the team. A vital job however.

6

Laurent RobertLaurent Robert

Not his day where the ball just wasn't reaching him. One or two lively moments and he did set up Shearer for his goal from a free-kick and looked at times our only real outlet but he got bogged down in the battle and went missing attacking wise. Worked hard overall but one or two signs of the lazy Robert did appear.

5

Alan ShearerAlan Shearer

A terrific performance from the No.9 unsettling Sporting's back-four with his strength and aerial prowess from the first to the last whistle. Planted a great header past Ricardo twice but had to settle for the one goal.

8

Shola AmeobiShola Ameobi

A frustrating game for Shola where many decisions went against him. He battled hard and tried but the service was shocking and anyone would struggle to control balls fizzed up to him at 90mph without thought or direction. When he did get on the ball with a bit of time to turn and play he got tangled up in his own legs. One to forget.

5


Substitutes:

Steve HarperSteve Harper

Came on for Given and produced a great save. A faultless display in a rare appearance from the No.2 'keeper.

6

James MilnerJames Milner

Came on for Robert on and looked lively and threatening. Should have doubled the lead but blazed his shot over the bar.

5

Lee BowyerLee Bowyer
Came on for Dyer to huge applause with Dyer also getting a undeserved reception from the home crowd. His first touch was also cheered and true to form, he picked up a yellow card. Other than that he hardly got on the ball. Lets hope this is the end of it all now and we can finally concentrate on the football.

5


The Boss Man:

Graeme SounessGraeme Souness

Picked the right lineup I feel and made the right changes when he had to. His side didn't play well, footballing wise they were awful but they stuck at it and battled hard, perhaps showing that there is plenty of spirit in the camp. He's handled the week pretty well and a win and a clean sheet is all we can ask for, especially given the last few days. Well done Souness.

7

Toon Shirts
Newcastle-Online.com Toon Shirts
Sponsors
Top | Club Info | Site Map | Contact | Advertise | Links | © Copyright | Newsnow