Newcastle-Online.com NUFC Supporters Forum Toon Ale - Wor Geordies Pride Is Deep Inside

Home

Season 2004-05

Nufc News Archive

Articles

St. James' Park

Toon Army

Nufc History

Nufc Forum

   
Articles Main

Toon Player Ratings Vs Portsmouth (a)


21st March 2005

By Gosport Toon

Shay GivenShay Given

Very little to do throughout the game but whatever he needed to do he did very well. Excellent save from a long range shot and generally appeared alert and on his toes as usual.

7

Stephen CarrStephen Carr

Provides plenty of energy and enthusiasm down the right hand side pushing forward to support the midfield and forwards. Worryingly, for when we play better opposition, he is sometimes caught out of position and his first touch lets him down at times.

7

Andy O'BrienAndy O'Brien

Seemed comfortable alongside Boumsong with no signs of any lapse in concentration. The only criticism was the three or four occasions he launched long balls that were nowhere near a Toon player, needlessly giving possession away. Maybe Titus needs to show him how to do them.

7

Jean-Alain BoumsongJean-Alain Boumsong

Boumsong was our best defender by a mile, constantly on his toes and looking to snuff out danger almost even before it had arrived. Accomplished in the air and on the ground, the only problem being he loses one or two 50/50 tackles in the game you'd expect him to win.

8

Aaron HughesAaron Hughes

Similar to O'Brien he seemed to have a reasonably comfortable game and although he didn't get many tackles in on Lua Lua he did make him turn back away from goal and pass the ball back on many occasions.

7

Lee BowyerLee Bowyer

Worked hard and had a good effort on goal saved by Ashdown and was involved in Dyer's goal. However, a la David Batty, he was too involved in petty skirmishes, particularly with Cisse which resulted in yet another booking.

7

Amdy FayeAmdy Faye

Won plenty of possession in the midfield area and played simple passes to his team mates to allow us to build up attacks on the Pompey goal. He did a good Makelele-type job for the team before being subbed in the second half.

7

Nicky Butt

Very composed but his lack of pace reduces his effectiveness, especially in any offensive sense. Possibly still getting back to his best after his injury lay-off. His poor distribution reminded me of Speed in his final season at SJP.

6

Laurent RobertLaurent Robert

Put in a few tackles and tried his best to create problems for the Pompey defence. However, Primus was quickly onto him whenever he got the ball and Laurent took his fair share of fouls. By the time he was substituted he was probably quite pleased to come off.

6

Alan ShearerAlan Shearer

Usually at his least effective when up against two or three tall defenders who are good in the air, and Saturday was no different. Tried hard but failed to create much for his colleagues or himself. Probably ready for a bit of well earned Dubai sun to recharge his batteries.

6

Kieron DyerKieron Dyer

"Roadrunner" was once again a threat to the opposition defence making darting runs across and through the Pompey backline. Just a shame he wasn't going through on goal when cynically brought down by Stefanovic which earned him a yellow card. Plus another goal to add to his collection. My man of the match.

8


Substitutes:

James MilnerJames Milner

Provided a bit more defensive steel but didn't inject any additional attacking thrust down the left wing.

5

Jermaine JenasJermaine Jenas

Brought a bit of extra pace and energy to the midfield with one or two surging runs, threatening to open up the Pompey defence but he lacked the killer pass/shot.

6

Patrick KluivertPatrick Kluivert

A bit unsure as to why PK was only given 5 minutes or so to make an impression. Worth a try to nick a late winner but lesser players than PK tend to get angry with their managers when used in this fashion. Maybe a two week break will bring the best out of Patrick and he will be the catalyst for at least one Cup and a move up the League.

6


The Boss Man:

Graeme SounessGraeme Souness

He obviously knows which players were fit and those carrying knocks and strains. Pompey were fighting for points to drag them away from the relegation abyss and a solid looking team was selected to counteract their physical approach to the game. We lost the winning run but stretched the unbeaten record and once again didn't let more than one goal in.

7

Toon Shirts
Newcastle-Online.com Toon Shirts
Sponsors
Top | Club Info | Site Map | Contact | Advertise | Links | © Copyright | Newsnow