Newcastle-Online.com NUFC Supporters Forum Toon Ale - Wor Geordies Pride Is Deep Inside

Home

Season 2004-05

Nufc News Archive

Articles

St. James' Park

Toon Army

Nufc History

Nufc Forum

   
Articles Main

Toon Player Ratings Vs SC Heerenveen (h)


25th February 2005

Shay GivenShay Given

One great save in the opening 10 minutes from Jan-Klaas Huntelaar and a couple of decent takes throughout the game for the Irishman who was largely untested. Had no chance with the spot-kick but deserved to keep a second successive clean sheet.

7

Stephen CarrStephen Carr

Another solid performance from the Republic of Ireland international who has looked the part since returning from injury. Got up and down the right flank all night and assisted the attack with clever link up play. In defence he had to cope with Bruggink often by himself as Dyer came infield from his right sided midfield slot. Slowly getting back to his best.

7

Andy O'BrienAndy O'Brien

A reasonably solid enough game up against a lightweight attack. He did get turned once or twice far to easily by Huntelaar however with one instance seeing the Dutch under 21 striker get a shot away which Shay did well to save. Not bad, but still a liability.

6.5

Titus BrambleTitus Bramble

Carried on from his super show against Chelsea at the weekend. Bramble didn't put a foot wrong and it's good to see the defender communicate with his fellow team-mates, make decisive decisions and organize his back four. An excellent performance.

8

Aaron HughesAaron Hughes

On this performance maybe we don't need cover for left-back in the Summer - he was superb. He defended well and in the attacking third he was a constant threat - linking up great with Robert as an overlapping full-back. Put in quite a few dangerous crosses (some with his left-foot) too and had an excellent game. Well done.

8

Kieron DyerKieron Dyer

Got at Heerenveen from the off and the Dutch side simply couldn't cope with his pace and runs which were penetrating. Advanced many a time into the box with and without the ball - creating space for others. Fell a sleep when their keeper parried an Ameobi shot as the ball was begging to be struck by the No.8 but other than that moment of head in the clouds, he put in an excellent shift. It has to be said however, the opposition midfield weren't exactly great and his tendency to drift inside is worrying as he often left Carr exposed. He needs to be disciplined out on the right and not wander infield all the time. Up against a better side, we will get punished down our right-flank. We missed his injection of pace and energy after the break though when he came off for Jenas. Not bad and improving.

7

Nicky Butt

Solid and effective. Broke up many of Heerenveen's play and drove on from midfield to support the attack. His distribution was much better too and his partnership with Faye in the centre gave us that solid platform to get at the visitors. Solid, no nonsense display.

7

Amdy FayeAmdy Faye

An unassuming game from the midfield man. Alongside Butt he played the deeper role and hardly got involved with play but was always there, pressing and closing down space. His use of the ball wasn't the greatest but he and Butt give the back-four added protection.

6

Laurent RobertLaurent Robert

He's here, he's there, he's every where... that was Robert against Heerenveen. Her was tremendous all night - an excellent game from the Frenchman. In the final 3rd his ball retention and link up play was superb and his crossing as good as ever with several dangerous balls whipped in from open play and set-pieces. Worked his socks off and helped out Hughes at all times defensively. My man of the match and it's a performance that bodes well for him and us if he can keep it up for the remainder of the season.

8.5

Alan ShearerAlan Shearer

At times he gave Petter Hansson the run around and bullied the Swede into submission but an injury knock picked up at the weekend was evident as his impact on this game was largely ineffective. Grabbed a great goal from a free kick however and did his job before being subbed for Milner into the second half.

6

Shola AmeobiShola Ameobi

A hot and cold night from the striker where he looked great in patches and shockingly awful in others. Could have had a hat-trick on another night but a combination of poor finishing, luck and great goalkeeping denied him. Gave away the penalty with a hand ball which was stupid of him as there was no danger of conceding. Towards the end he demonstrated just why he will never be a goalscorer and with that a regular for Newcastle. 3 times United broke clear, with 2 men up over Heerenveen in the dying moments and on each occasion Shola made it impossible for the man on the ball to pull it back for him to score by his static movement. In the box all by himself with Hansson drawn to Robert twice and Milner once, Ameobi simply went to the ball instead of stepping off and giving his man an option to play him in. Had he had a bit more savvy, he could have been one on one with their 'keeper. Instead his lack of movement forced Robert and Milner to take shots.

6


Substitutes:

Jermaine JenasJermaine Jenas

Came on at half-time for Dyer, slotting in on the right of midfield and did nothing of any noteworthy mention as the game passed him by. Looks tired and in need of more than a 45 minute break. The Dubai trip hasn't done him any good...

4

James MilnerJames Milner

Came on for Shearer into the second half and initially player down the middle before reverting to a right flank role later on with Souness switching to a 4-5-1 formation. Tried to get involved and worked hard to get into the game to make an impact but he needs more than the latter stages of a game to make his mark.

5

Steven TaylorSteven Taylor

Came on for O'Brien towards the end, slotting in at centre-half and was hardly in the game as the ball and play was up at the other end.

4


The Boss Man:

Graeme SounessGraeme Souness

Stuck with 4-4-2 which was pleasing and decided to rest Jenas, going with Faye and Butt in midfield. Tactics were pretty much spot on - get the goals, kill them off and ease up for Sunday's visit of Bolton. He would have been angry with their late goal and rightly so because they never looked like scoring all night. His decision to start with Robert was rewarded with a great performance from the Frenchman and subbing Big Al was the correct decision. A great end to a great week for the Scot. Well done Graeme.

7

Toon Shirts
Newcastle-Online.com Toon Shirts
Sponsors
Top | Club Info | Site Map | Contact | Advertise | Links | © Copyright | Newsnow